Easily order and customize a catering feast of First Class Pizza, Bagel Me! & Sugar Me Bakery favorites for breakfast, lunch, and dinner that scales to any sized get-together. First Class Pizza provides event and party catering including corporate and office catering.
Take a look at our Catering Menu below, and once you’re ready to place your order, you can either order online or call us at 714-639-1438.
Delivery charge of $10.00 or 7% of order before tax applies.
48 hours advance notice is appreciated. Please call us if a shorter time frame is necessary. Cancellations less than 24 hours before delivery time will be charged for 50% of order. No charge for cancellations 24 hours before delivery.
The First Class Pizza East Orange location has three concepts in one location. Bagel Me!, First Class Pizza and The Sugar Me Bakery. Catering is available for all.
Create Your Own Pizza
Served after 11am Daily
~special orders available earlier~
10″ Pizza 6 slices
Cheese $9.95 One Topping $1.29 Cheese Blanket $1.29
12″ Pizza 8 slices
Cheese $13.95 One Topping $1.79 Cheese Blanket $1.79
14″ Pizza 10 slices
Cheese $15.95 One Topping $1.99 Cheese Blanket $1.99
16″ Pizza 12 slices
Cheese $17.95 One Topping $2.39 Cheese Blanket $2.39
Customize your crust and request any pizza as thin crust!
Cheese Blanket
Extra layer of mozzarella on top with Parmesan and seasonings
Meat Toppings
Pepperoni ~ Bacon Pieces* ~ Canadian Bacon ~ Salami ~ Italian Sausage ~
Anchovies ~ Chicken Breast* ~ Hamburger ~ Chicken Tenders ~ Meatballs ~ Capicola
Veggie Toppings
Mushrooms ~ Red Onion ~ Roma Tomato ~ Artichoke Hearts* ~ Sun-Dried Tomato ~ Green Bell Pepper ~ Red Bell Pepper
Cheese Toppings
Mozzarella ~ Tillamook Cheddar ~ Swiss ~ Parmesan ~ Romano ~ Feta ~ Pepper Jack ~ Provolone ~ Monterey Jack ~ Crumbled Bleu Cheese
Other Toppings
Fresh Garlic (free) ~ Cilantro ~ Wax Peppers ~ Black Olives ~ Fresh Basil ~ Italian Seasonings (free) ~ Jalapeños ~ Pepperoncinis ~ Crushed Red Pepper (free)
Sauces
Our traditional, made from scratch Red Sauce
Pesto Sauce ~ Alfredo Sauce ~ Olive Oil ~ Ranch Dressing ~ BBQ Sauce
Specialty Pizzas
Served after 11am Daily
We are famous for our very large portions.
SM $15.95 MED $20.95 LG $25.95 XLG $28.95
COMBO
A big favorite! Pepperoni, fresh sliced mushrooms, green bell peppers, red onion and fresh Italian sausage, mozzarella, red sauce
MEATLOVER’S
Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, bacon, meatballs and fresh Italian sausage, mozzarella, red sauce
SM $14.75 MED $18.79 LG $23.45 XLG $27.30
BBQ CHICKEN
Loaded with grilled chicken breast, fresh garlic, red onion, seasonings, BBQ sauce, fresh cilantro, mozzarella, red sauce
VEGGIE PIZZA
Veggies piled high covered with a topping of light mozzarella cheese, fresh mushrooms, black olives, tomato, fresh garlic, red onion, green and red bell peppers, seasonings, grated Parmesan cheese, mozzarella, red sauce
BUFFALO CHICKEN
All white meat chicken with mozzarella over ranch dressing sauce, tomato, red onion, crumbled bleu cheese, Buffalo sauce, basil
THE TUSCANY
Genoa salami, spicy Capicola, fresh Italian sausage, shredded Parmesan, seasonings, fresh basil, marinara sauce, mozzarella
ARTICHOKE PEPPERONI
Artichoke, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, onion, Roma tomato, fresh Italian Seasonings
GREAT WHITE
Alfredo sauce, fresh mushrooms, grilled chicken breast, shredded parmesan
SM $14.75 MED $18.79 LG $23.45 XLG $27.30
SM $13.40 MED $16.95 LG $19.95 XLG $23.95
BASILICIOUS
Fresh basil, fresh garlic, Roma tomatoes, seasoning
HAWAIIAN
Canadian bacon, chunks of sweet pineapple over red sauce and mozzarella
KICK ‘N CHICKEN
Fresh mushrooms, grilled chicken breast, fresh garlic, seasonings
CLASSICO
Extra mozzarella, Roma tomato, fresh garlic, seasonings, olive oil
ULTIMATE THIN CRUST
Pepperoni, shredded Parmesan, fresh garlic, seasonings, sliced pepperoncini
SM $13.40 MED $16.95 LG $19.95 XLG $23.95
Pasta
Single orders served with Garlic Breadstix
Spaghetti Marinara
Single Order $7.95 Up to 15 $39.95 Up to 30 $74.95
Spaghetti & Meat Sauce
Single Order $9.25 Up to 15 $45.95 Up to 30 $86.95
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Single Order $9.25 Up to 15 $45.95 Up to 30 $86.95
Baked Lasagna with Fettucini Pasta Marinara Sauce
Single Order $10.95 Up to 15 $49.95 Up to 30 $91.95
Fettucini Alfredo
Single Order $8.75 Up to 15 $42.75 Up to 30 $83.75
Chicken & Broccoli Fettucini
Single Order $10.75 Up to 15 $49.95 Up to 30 $91.95
Chicken & Mushroom Fettucini
Single Order $10.75 Up to 15 $49.95 Up to 30 $91.95
Specialty Salads
Tray $37.95 serves up to 15 Two Trays $71.95 serves up to 30
Served with Cheese Garlic Stix
Great Garden Salad
House greens, cucumbers, avocado, broccoli, mushrooms, red bell peppers, green bell peppers, white onion, shredded carrots, mozzarella, tomato, ranch dressing.
Southwestern Chicken Salad
Chicken breast, avocado, black beans, kernel corns, Boarshead Vermont cheddar, Monterey Jack, white onion, tomato, fresh cilantro, tortilla strips, spicy ranch dressing.
BBQ Ranch Chicken Salad
Chicken breast, black beans, fresh cilantro, kernel corn, onion, tomato, Boarshead Vermont cheddar, Monterey Jack, tortilla strips, Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ sauce.
Chicken Artichoke Salad
Chicken breast, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, artichokes, grape tomato, house greens, Balsamic Vinaigrette.
Fresh Fruit Tray
One Tray $33.95 serves up to 15
Two Trays $63.95 serves up to 30
The Sugar Me Bakery
Dessert Bar Platter $54.25
An assortment of 36 petite Lemon Bars, Raspberry Almond Bars, Triple Chocolate Walnut Brownies, Pecan Bars
Jumbo Buttercream Cupcakes
everyday flavors $48.00 per dozen
specialty flavors $50.10 per dozen
Standard and Mini Sizes Available
Round or Sheet Cakes
15% discount when ordered with catering
48 hour notice
(extra design may require more than 48 hours)
Fresh Baked Cookies $14.95 per dozen
* Platter packaging add $3.00
Chocolate Chip Walnut, Snickerdoodle, M&M Chocolate Chip, M&M
Our Famous Pumpkin Cookies with cinnamon icing (seasonal)
Bagel Me!
The Best Bagels on Earth
sourdough, garlic, onion, cheese, cheese onion, cheese jalapeño, cheese everything, sesame seed, everything, salt, poppyseed, glazer, whole wheat glazer, cinnamon raisin, energy bar, multigrain, plain, jalapeño, very berry, strawberry, blueberry, chocolate chip, pumpkin (seasonal)
Bagels by the Dozen $14.95
Cream Cheese 8oz & 16oz
Breakfast Egg Melts
$8.65 Each
served with cinnamon baked apples
Egg, Cheddar, Bacon
Egg, Cheddar, Sausage
Egg, Cheddar, Ham
Chipotle Bacon Egg Melt
applewood smoked bacon, Tillamook cheddar, chipotle sauce
Egg, Jack, Avocado & Tomato
Egg, Cheddar & Veggie
mushrooms, zucchini, yellow squash, bell peppers, broccoli, onion
Jumbo Muffins
$2.50 Each
Coffee Cake, Blueberry, Lemon Poppyseed, Chocolate Chip, Peach
Beverages
2 Liter Sode $2.75
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr Pepper, Diet Dr Pepper
Fresh Squeezed OJ